+- Frictional Games Forum (read-only) (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Penumbra: Overture, Black Plague & Requiem (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-20.html)
+--- Thread: Should Penumbra continue? (/thread-16725.html)
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Sexbad - 07-06-2012
(07-04-2012, 11:49 PM)spukrian Wrote: The Penumbra story is done. Though I'd love a new game involving elements from Penumbra, like the Archaic.I agree. The story behind the organization is so vast and I think it could really use some in-game expansion. I just hope they get Tom Jubert back as writer if they ever decide to continue Penumbra in some way.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Tobbe - 07-07-2012
It annoys me that people are typing ''penumbra story is done'' and things like that. So is Amnesia the dark descent. amnesia amfp isn't going after daniels story. People said the same thing about amnesia before amfp was announced. So why isn't is possible to make a new penumbra? or just do it as amfp, in the same universe.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Kazakarumariou - 07-07-2012
I'd rather have a new story. Something new and something fresh. I'm sure Frictional games could create another amazing game. They have some crazy vivid minds.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Damascus Rose - 07-07-2012
(07-07-2012, 03:23 AM)Tobbe Wrote: It annoys me that people are typing ''penumbra story is done'' and things like that. So is Amnesia the dark descent. amnesia amfp isn't going after daniels story. People said the same thing about amnesia before amfp was announced. So why isn't is possible to make a new penumbra? or just do it as amfp, in the same universe.I imagine the plotlines aren't that related, and it's called an amnesia game because it has the same style and premise as amnesia tdd. You could say that the penumbra story and amnesia story all happened in the same universe, we have no real proof otherwise.
After people finished Amnesia they were desperate for more amnesia because it was only a one game deal, penumbra had three games.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Tobbe - 07-07-2012
(07-07-2012, 04:40 AM)Damascus Rose Wrote:Well, it can be a differentt game, but the title can still be there. I'm pretty sure that you can have a different plot with ''penumbra'' as a title.(07-07-2012, 03:23 AM)Tobbe Wrote: It annoys me that people are typing ''penumbra story is done'' and things like that. So is Amnesia the dark descent. amnesia amfp isn't going after daniels story. People said the same thing about amnesia before amfp was announced. So why isn't is possible to make a new penumbra? or just do it as amfp, in the same universe.I imagine the plotlines aren't that related, and it's called an amnesia game because it has the same style and premise as amnesia tdd. You could say that the penumbra story and amnesia story all happened in the same universe, we have no real proof otherwise.
After people finished Amnesia they were desperate for more amnesia because it was only a one game deal, penumbra had three games.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Damascus Rose - 07-07-2012
Why would you want to? Penumbra is the title representing the series with Phillip in the Archaic. You can't just slap that name on something else.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Tobbe - 07-07-2012
(07-07-2012, 05:16 AM)Damascus Rose Wrote: Why would you want to? Penumbra is the title representing the series with Phillip in the Archaic. You can't just slap that name on something else.Search up what penumbra means
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - MaZiCUT - 07-07-2012
What's the point of having a different plot and still calling it Penumbra?
Let there be another modern horror game instead, like Penumbra but it can be located in Chernobyl >
or somewhere in an abandoned place in Russia.
Cause Russia is scary 'nuff said.
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Damascus Rose - 07-07-2012
I know what penumbra means, but it has come to represent Phillip's story. You can't put that name on something else..
RE: Should Penumbra continue? - Tobbe - 07-07-2012
(07-07-2012, 03:49 PM)Damascus Rose Wrote: I know what penumbra means, but it has come to represent Phillip's story. You can't put that name on something else..So Amnesia represents Daniel?
(07-07-2012, 11:51 AM)GeneralGregsworth Wrote: What's the point of having a different plot and still calling it Penumbra?That would be cool!
Let there be another modern horror game instead, like Penumbra but it can be located in Chernobyl >
or somewhere in an abandoned place in Russia.
Cause Russia is scary 'nuff said.