How would you want a plot to be presented?

[Tomato Cat]

Now, I'm not asking for instruction on creative writing. I'm simply
wondering how this community likes its custom story plots to be
articulated.

Ignoring the cliche, lets say that your character wanted to exact
revenge. How would you want something like that to be presented?

As you probably could tell, I'm working on my own story. And I wanted it
to be rather unique. But I'm having a bit of difficulty in leading the story on and making the player feel the
struggle of the protagonist. Again, I'm not asking for anyone to write the story for me. All I want is your input on what can make an interesting and immersive story, well, interesting and immersive.