Amnesia: The Dark Descent or Penumbra: The Black Plague?

[cantremember]

My Black Plague likes:
- more direction confrontations with monsters, who don't disappear. In Amnesia it's just, hear the music, hide, wait for music to stop & come back out

- More scary setting (Amnesia was too much like a haunted house)

My Amnesia likes:
- Sanity system

- More dark areas

- Better graphics