What is the absolute scariest cs you've ever played?

[Newsman Waterpaper]

Um.

White Night is overrated to high heaven, and pretty damn poor in many respects (Seriously, it's shite. Don't bother.). La Caza is buggy, and I was pretty bored by it all. Through the Portal was pretty good, though not that scary.
Palistov's holiday series is pretty good. Library of Alexandria was pretty good and scary.

I have to agree, White night is overrated.
I suggest trying out the trapdoor, to me it's the scariest and most well made amnesia CS/ Full conversion that you can find out there.