Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs Discussion Topic Part 1

[Bridge]

Grip himself was even unsure if Amnesia at all is a "game" yet.
I think, games normally are for fun. But Amnesia is not for fun, it's like some kind of serious games.

Of course it's supposed to be and is fun. You're just arguing the semantics of the word "fun" and you seem to think that "fun" is synonymous with "shallow" and "immersion-breaking". To me "fun" is something I enjoy playing because it is well made, has smooth controls and is not boring. That doesn't mean I consider Amnesia just a way to pass time. You could also argue the semantics of "game"; there is no shame attached to the word because a game is just an interactive artform. Just like "movie" and "song" have no negative connotations (unless you're an elitist douchebag). Why not disperse with all the pointless bullshit and just talk about the aesthetic qualities the game has?

EDIT: Also, I hate to break this to you, but Thomas is just a human being like you and me. He is not God and while he has a lot of good ideas when it comes to horror he also has many questionable and perhaps even detrimental ideas. Don't pretend like you have a deeper understanding of horror just by quoting him because you don't.