Amnesia Doesn't Scare Me...

[xdeath]

But that doesn't mean it isn't fun as hell. I think the monsters are, dare I say...cute and funny. Please see this video for details.

Lol, I think you did find it scary. Your mind made the monsters seam "cute and funny" as a defence mechanism.
As others said, the meme status of monsters made the game a lot less scary, because our minds associate the monster with those pictures.
"Fear of the Unknown" was Amnesias strength, but that it has been torn up and put back together as "cute and funny", or worse "sexy". You look at the monster and suddenly think "bro".
Thank You PewDiePie for ruining this game.