Which monster scared you the most and why?

[Paddy]

It's really interesting to read everyone's replies here, they reveal how differently people relate/respond to different things. Maybe this will be good data for thechineseroom!

I found the Suitors to be the least frightening. The only time a Suitor made me feel the same kind of fear I felt from a Brute or Grunt was [SPOILER!!!!!!!!!!!!] when I was crawling through the ceiling after saving the first prisoner and thought a Suitor was coming behind me [END OF SPOILER!]. I found them to be more of an annoyance than a threat, at least compared to the enemies in The Dark Descent. Obviously when the various enemies are chasing you they're all as frightening as each other haha.