Is the collaboration with TCR good or bad?

[Oink]

You shouldn't really judge something until you've experienced it. After all, we all have different tastes.

As for the old 'gameplay' argument - that's a discussion for another thread, but ultimately - why restrict something by pigeon-holing it? What's wrong with experimenting and being different?

Hehe, I'm not gonna judge AAMFP before playing it, that's for sure. I might try out the Dear Esther mod, it was free IIRC.

I'm not restricting or pigeonholing anything - unless you count the fact that I like some stuff and dislike some other stuff. As for not trying Dear Esther, I feel like I've read enough opinions about the game to know what to expect from it.

There's certainly nothing wrong with experimentation and being different!

I wouldn't form a judgement based on the original Dear Esther mod if I were you - not that it's bad, but it's very rough around the edges and isn't a patch on the far superior retail version.