Better entrance? Grunt or Brute?

[HateSolstice]

The Brute's entrance had been far more brutal than the Grunt's.

DOH SNAP.

Imo, the grunt's execution was superior. Although it's not confirmed, doesn't the wine cellar event have something to do with the origin of the grunts? At the very least,there is a note in the archives about the "gatherers"; it seems the grunt had much more of a back story than the brute, which to me is just as important as the sounds/visuals for building up suspense (not to say the grunt didn't have those as well).

In all fairness though, the brute character couldn't work the same way; trying to maintain the intense atmosphere in the middle of the game while trying to revert to those same tactics to build suspense would most likely ruin the mood and pace. There was almost no subtlety involved in the brute's build up, it was simply seeing him walking down a long corridor a few times, listening to him murder a few prisoners off in the distance, then finished off with him kicking down a door in the morgue. It felt a bit rushed to me.

I felt the prison was a very nice build-up. Besides, if you played the game with the correct gamma setting, you could barely see him anyway.