Games in which you felt more immersed than in Amnesia

[Zgroktar]

Everything that Penumbra does, Amnesia does better, and the same is of the immersion. Penumbra is a good game, but at times is too much flawed and incomplete. That ruins the immersion for me.

You played Amnesia first, right?

No, I've played Penumbra first. At the end of the last year did I played Amnesia for the first time.

---

Everything that Penumbra does, Amnesia does better, and the same is of the immersion. Penumbra is a good game, but at times is too much flawed and incomplete. That ruins the immersion for me.

BP was better to me than TDD was but I get your point that the movement and handling is kinda spastic would be nice if they would do a HQ remake of it sometime.

That wasn't my point, the movement and handling are of a minor importance for me. Amnesia is better in the elements of the story, atmosphere, and is many times more horrifying than Penumbra. For me Penumbra, while a decent game, just doesn't deliver quite a punch like Amnesia.