The Best Penumbra? Vote!

[TaCTiCaLxReFLeX]

Okay here is how I think about it.... Fun, Scary ,Story, Overall

1.Penumbra Overture: 7/10 _______ 5/10 _________ 8/10 _______ 8/10


2. Penumbra Black Plague: 9/10 ____ 9/10 _________10/10 ___ 10/10


3.Penumbra Requiem: 3/10 ________0/10 __________ 1/10 ________3/10



In my opinion Requiem was a huge let down......... let me hear yours about the other penumbras!!!

[CorinthianMerchant]

Requiem is my favorite!

[Unearthlybrutal]

Overture or Black Plague.
Overture has the best atmosphere, but Black Plague was much scarier.

[BrooksyFC]

1) Overture has some great puzzles and story.


2) Black Plague is a LOT scarier and has some cool puzzles.

3) Requiem I am yet to play, but heard it's not very scary.

I'll go Overture as I've completed it and the story and ending were amazing.

[darkely]

I am not sure why people are rateing Overture and Black Plague's storys seperatley. The plot simply continues...

1. Overture it was good loved the story but the mines got repetitive -.-
2. Black Plauge has a great story as does Overture ...towards the end when Phillip...

Spoiler below!

completes the tests and the monster (I forget its name) begs for mercy and Phillip lies and turns around and tells his friend to kill them all

.
3. Requiem playing it now.