Amnesia dark descent vs penumbra black plague

[maarten12100]

I found BP just a terrifien as ATD
And the fact the story continued where OT ended was great too.

Penumbra Requiem-ZERO enemies,
purely a puzzle game.It is fun but this doesn't fit into the series and
thus it is a huge dissapointment.Worst of all 3 penumbras by far.

this I was completing all those puzzels in a gloomy warehouse.
Too find myself at the end with nothing happend.
I just had to play with allot of balls (You guys know that I don't like playing with others balls)

Btw the controls are a definite + for amnesia since the controlls in Penumbra where a bit stiff.
And you couldn't rotate objects you could just hassle around with them extremely hard to stack stuff together.