After playing Amnesia, is Penumbra any good?

[Crabski]

YES, play it. Penumbra's definitely more dated and less polished (since they had less money to work with and all), but I still consider Black Plague to be the scariest game of the three. Having the flashlight instead of the lantern just makes everything more terrifying

I still consider the Kennel section of Black Plague to be the single most frightening thing I've ever experienced.