Custom story: Courage [Canceled]

[Frontcannon]

I won't go into details, but 4chan and associates are no stranger to me.
So I am sure when I say: gore isn't scary. It even has the opposite effect!

You fear what you don't know. That's why monster encounters in Amnesia are so scarce. If you would show the player the butcher and his actions so openly, why would there be a reason to fear him?
Pyramid Head in Silent Hill 2 had very few appearances, too, so I think using the Butcher as a mysterious figure that would show every so often and the player discovering his mad butchering sessions (but don't go overboard there, desensitisation must be avoided) could make the encounters with the Butcher way scarier.