Amnesia Doesn't Scare Me...

[Juby]

Amnesia is not entirely scary.

Let me explain, Amnesia creates fear and an experience. Scary is a "jumpscare" such as a door breaking right when you close it or something. Fear is a distressing emotion aroused by impending danger, pain, etc., whether the threat is real or being imagined. It's the feeling of being afraid. The game creates various other things, but the main thing is an experience. To get this "experience", you immerse yourself fully. Your not pretending anything if your immersed; in this case, you are Daniel (not playing as him) and you need to kill Alexander and you only have one life. Otherwise, if your not Daniel, you haven't immersed yourself, period. Although, not everyone will be as afraid as anybody else, at least you'll get the experience and you don't have to think it is "scary" or not, just enjoy the experience, which it looks like the OP has done.