Opinions on how TCR & FG are dealing with AAMFP criticism

[PutraenusAlivius]

-hiding from monstrosities

Only done a total of four times in AMFP, considering it's short length, hardly a core component.

-having no means of defense
-reliance on light-source that also attracts attention

Rendered meaningless with the lack of enemy encounters.

-dark historical setting
-an unpleasant protagonist
-use of audio flashbacks and diary entries

Elements of storytelling that are hardly unique to Amnesia.

-emphasis on exploration

There's no need to explore in AMFP, the "puzzles" solve themselves and the environments are extremely linear.

If you get rid of everything this game has in common with its predecessor, of course you're not gonna find anything that you like. Cherry-picking is fun when combined with a dash of arrogance.

?

TCR had a different goal than FG. Who's to say that sequels must be exactly like the predecessor?