Opinions on how TCR & FG are dealing with AAMFP criticism

[Alardem]

What that really indicates to me is that the established fan-base is hating on a sequel that wasn't a clone of the first game. Give it a few more months and the scores should even out.

Again, we're going back to the discussion about whether this game would fare better if it wasn't billed as a follow-up to Amnesia. Personally, it SHOULDN'T matter and I tend to love sequels that don't directly emulate the original (all the better to get new fans), but apparently people were expecting Amnesia 1 all over again.

I think that if it were up to the fans, we'd have a story about Daniel going to another haunted castle and getting hunted by red goop. Again.