Daniel vs Mandus

[Alardem]

Daniel was dumb enough to kidnap an innocent family and murder a little girl, and not strong enough to deal with that knowledge.

This is a moot point, really. They're both vile characters in their own manner prior to their gaining amnesia - Mandus is a misanthrope with a savior complex and access to extremely potent killing machines, while Daniel's cowardice meant the painful death of dozens. Mandus was lucky enough to literally split his soul in half, while Daniel was effectively the same person except without his memories.

I didn't include Justine in this poll, but I actually like her character a lot. Despite being more fragile than the likes of the men, she at least manages to keep her faculties when confronted by monsters and, just like Daniel, she can be played as a selfless, compassionate person. The only problem is that she never attempts redemption like Oswald or Danny. She revels in her evil, rather than coming up with silly rationalizations or trying to stick her head in the sand.