Amnesia: Justine Discussion Topic

[Som1Lse]

That is one that got me thinking as well.
I got it on my first try, although that was mostly guesswork.

I am replaying that part right now, trying to figure out what it is.

Edit:
I came up with some stuff.
I haven't thought all of this over and I probably missed a quite few things.
But anyway. Here you go:

Spoiler below!

==Slidies==
1: A man with open arms. Facing left. (X)
2: A man with a sword. Facing left. (Kills the prisoner)
3: A praying man. Facing right. (2)
4: A man who sees things he likes. Facing right. (1)

==Phonograph==
On this next piece you should be looking for some divine inspiration. Time to delve into your spiritual side.
What do you see? Is the man begging for mercy or is he being blessed.
Perhaps both! Father used to say, there were no right answers.
Have the light guide you.

==Results==
Using the Puzzle Lock has proven more difficult as she tends to always choose two slides with characters facing the same way. I have asked her why this is, but she doesn't seem to fully understand what I am asking.

==The prisoner==
You can easily figure out he is a priest.
A lot of what he says hints at it, and if you look at the right wall you can see a picture of a prisoner. (the golden cross neclase is the hint)

==Soul Journal Entries==
Justine, age 8
Today I played outside with Clarice. We saw a bird pick at a snail. It carried it off and landed on the lawn fence. The snail had a shell and it cracked. Clarice cried and I comforted her.
The new maid heard us and came out and scolded Clarice for playing with me, the bird took off into the air.

Today I was the one with open arms.


Justine, age 9
Today I played with the slides from father's Light Box. Above all I like the man standing to the right. Father asked why.
I said, he see things he likes.

Today I was the right one.


Justine, age 10
Father said I picked the wrong slide yesterday when I made the chambermaid cry. He wanted me to pick the one with the sword, while I picked the man on the right.
I never pick the one with the sword.

Today I was the one kneeling.


Justine, age 11
Today father came for me in my room. I still couldn't look him in the eyes. He said I shouldn't feel ashamed and that I only tried to fill the void left by mother.
When he wasn't looking I took the star stone from his collection.

Today I was the one with the sword.

==Conclusions==
She hates the man with the sword, and if you choose it, the prisoner dies instantly.

The right combination consists of two men facing the same direction as hinted at in the results note. (Justine was the one who choosed the new combination for the current puzzle)
The man who sees things he likes (4) is obviously one of the required ones. It is also Justines favorite. She picks it when she is happy. Thus it goes into the first one.
You are asked whether he is begging for mercy (praying) or is being blessed. (phonograph)
The one with open arms is blessed but something died that day (the snail), and Clarice cried.
He is also a priest so praying (begging for mercy) is obvious.

If you choose any other combination he is tortured. Except for the right combination. If you fail four times he dies.